SPECIAL PRE-ELECTION EDITION
November 5th: The (Not Really) General Election OR
November 5th: The General Election is Not as General as You Think
Senate - 57% De facto Elected + 29% Heavily Favored = 86% Mostly Set
House – 44% De facto Elected + 30% Heavily Favored = 74% Mostly Set
Voting is how the people give consent to those that will govern them. Starting on September 20th voting begins and the people will decide the make up of the next legislature, except for the races that have already been determined which is 57% of the Senate and 44% of the House of Representatives. Below you will find an analysis of the districts that have already determined who will serve and a look at the number of districts that have heavily favored incumbents running.
Looking at the Senate. South Dakota has 35 Legislative Districts and each district elects one Senator. The Senate has 35 members. This November, 18 of the 35 seats (51%) have no opponent facing the winner of the primary. Some had no primary opponent either. This means there are 17 districts (49%) that have contested elections.
Looking at the 17 contested races, there are 2 of the 18 races that have experienced incumbent members running against registered independents who have never elected anyone to office. This means there are 20 people (57%) who are de facto - or nearly de facto - elected.
In addition to the 18 districts with either no contest or very unlikely opponents, there are 5 that have strong incumbents currently serving in the Senate from these districts and 5 districts with experienced House incumbents, people who have been elected from the district to the House of Representatives. It is also fair to point out that more incumbents than usual were defeated in the primary election. Even with this in mind, adding the 10 strong incumbents to the 20 with no contest means as many as 30 of the 35 seats have either completely known outcomes or very likely outcomes.
Here is the list of the de facto “Senators-elect” that have no opponent in the general election: Symbols – (R)=Republican; (D)=Democrat; (I)=Incumbent; (N)=New
· District 1 – Michael Rohl, Aberdeen (R) (I)
· District 2 Steve Kolbeck, Brandon (R) (I)
· District 3 Carl Perry, Aberdeen (R) (I-House)
· District 4 Stephanie Sauder (R) (I-House)
· District 6 Ernie Otten, Tea (R) (I-House)
· District 7 Tim Reed, Brookings (R) (I)
· District 8 Casey Crabtree, Madison (R) (I)
· District 9 Joy Hohn, Hartford (R) (N)
· District 10 Liz Larson, Sioux Falls (D) (I)
· District 16 Kevin Jensen, Canton (R) (I-House)
· District 17 Sydney Davis, Burbank (R) (I)
· District 20 Paul Miskimins, Mitchell (R) (Returning)
· District 23 Mark Lapka, Leola (R) (N)
· District 24 Jim Mehlhaff, Pierre (R) (I)
· District 29 John Carley, Piedmont (R) (N)
· District 31 Randy Deibert, Spearfish (R) (I)
· District 33 Curt Voight, Rapid City (R) (N)
· District 35 Greg Blanc, Rapid City (R) (N)
These two districts have incumbents running against people registered as independents that have not elected anyone to office.
· District 32 Helene Duhamel, Rapid City (R) (I) vs IND Karen McNeal, Rapid City
· District 19 Kyle Schoenfish, Scotland (R) (I) vs IND Michael Miller, Freeman
Looking at the races for the House of Representatives. The same 35 legislative districts elect 2 people each to serve in the House of Representatives. This results in the House having 70 members, which can mean that it is a bit crowded in there. When you add a hundred or more lobbyists and a handful of family members, the place can look like a New York subway platform.
There are 13.5 districts that were determined by the primary election because of a lack of any opponent in the fall. The “half” of a district is because two of the legislative districts have been divided by the courts and each half of those districts elects a single member rather the electing two from the entire districts. In District 26A, one of the seats has been determined while the other one is being contested.
To start over. There are 13.5 districts that have already determined winners, meaning 27 members (39%) of the House are set. That leaves 21.5 districts with contested races for 43 seats.
There are two districts with contested races but have opponents registered with the Libertarian party that has never elected anyone to the legislature. With the extreme likelihood that the registered Republican candidates will be successful, this brings the total of seats in the House that are de facto determined to 31 (44%). Now there are 19.5 districts with contested races, sort of.
Looking at those 19.5 contested races, which represent 39 seats (56%), there are 10.5 of those districts with strong incumbents running against first time or lesser-known candidates. This means, under usual circumstances, these 21 incumbents combined with the 31 already de facto-elected results in a total of 52 (74%) of the total House has a good chance of being known already. It is also fair to point out that more incumbents than usual were defeated in the primary election.
The following districts have no contested races, meaning these people have been de facto elected: Symbols – (R)=Republican; (D)=Democrat; (I)=Incumbent; (N)=New
· District 2: David Kull, Brandon (R) (I) and John Sjaarda, Valley Springs (R) (I)
· District 4: Kent Roe, Hayti (R) (N) and Dylan Jordan, Clear Lake (R) (N)
· District 13: Tony Venhuizen, Sioux Falls (R) (I) and John Hughes, Sioux Falls (R) (N)
· District 19: Drew Peterson, Salem (R) (I) and Jessica Bahmuller, Alexandria (R) (I)
· District 20: Jeff Bathke, Mitchell (R) (N) and Kaley Nolz, Mitchell (R) (N)
· District 21: Jim Halverson, Winner (R) (N) and Marty Overweg, New Holland (R) (I)
· District 22: Lana Greenfield, Doland (R) (Return) and Kevin Van Diepen, Huron (R) (N)
· District 23: Spencer Gosch, Glenham (R) (Returning) and Scott Moore, Ipswich (R) (I)
· District 24: Will Mortenson, Fort Pierre (R) (I) and Mike Weisgram, Pierre (R) (I)
· District 25: Les Heinemann, Flandreau (R) (Return) and Jon Hansen, Dell Rapids (R) (I)
· District 29: Kathy Rice, Black Hawk (R) (N) and Terri Jorgenson, Rapid City (R) (N)
· District 33: Phil Jensen, Rapid City (R) (I) and Curt Massie, Rapid City (R) (I)
· District 34: Mike Derby, Rapid City (R) (I) and Heather Baxter, Rapid City (R) (N)
· District 28B: Travis Ismay, Newell (R) (N)
These districts have contests with opponents that are registered independents or registered with the Libertarian Party which has had no success in electing anyone to the legislature.
· District 8: Tim Reisch, Howard (R) (I) and Tim Walburg, Madison (R) (N) vs Greg Zimmerman, Wentworth (Lib) (N)
· District 31: Scott Odenbach, Spearfish (R) (I) and Mary Fitzgerald, Saint Onge (R) (I) vs Shana McVickers, Spearfish (IND) (N) and Victoria Greenlee, Spearfish (IND) (N)
General Election Ballot Measures
There are seven ballot measures being decided on the general election which will be on November 5th, 2024, with absentee voting starting on September 20th this year.
The seven ballot measures include four amendments to the Constitution, two proposed laws, and one referendum which is a law that was passed by the legislature that has been referred to the public for a vote.
Here is a list of the titles for the ballot measures:
· An amendment to the Constitution of the State of South Dakota, updating references to certain officeholders and persons.
· An amendment to the Constitution of the State of South Dakota, authorizing the state to impose work requirements on certain individuals who are eligible for expanded Medicaid.
· An amendment to the South Dakota Constitution Establishing Top-Two Primary Elections.
· An initiated Amendment Establishing a Right to Abortion in the State Constitution.
· An Initiated Measure Prohibiting Taxes on Anything Sold for Human Consumption.
· An Initiated Measure Legalizing the Recreational Use, Possession, and Distribution of Marijuana.
· A Referred Act to Provide New Statutory Requirements for Regulating Linear Transmission Facilities, to Allow Counties to Impose a Surcharge on Certain Pipeline Companies, and to Establish a Landowner Bill of Rights.
The Secretary of State has a pamphlet in which the proponents and opponents of each ballot measure make their arguments for and against these proposals. That pamphlet is available here:
2024GeneralBQPamphlet.FINALdocx.pdf (sdsos.gov)
The South Dakota Chamber of Commerce and Industry will be evaluating these proposals and will send that analysis to the membership in the near future. Thank you for your support of this work.
2024 Economic Outlook Reminder
Event details at https:/bit.ly/4bWHmC5
What do the leading economists know that you should know?
Join the discussion with Joe Santos, Ph.D., Director & Professor of Economics, Ness School of Management, oversees Dykhouse Program, South Dakota State University and Jared McEntaffer, Ph.D., CEO, chief economist, Dakota Institute for Business and Economic Analysis.
Session moderated by Tony Nour, SVP Relationship Banking, PREMIER Bankcard.
Want to better understand cybersecurity and Artificial Intelligence?
Bring your questions to the discussion with
Cybersecurity expert and CEO of DARC Andrea Thompson
Artificial Intelligence David De Jong, Ed.D., Dakota State University
Private cybersecurity Kimberly Hogstad, Vice President - Information Security Officer, Sanford Health
The cybersecurity and artificial intelligence discussion will be moderated by Jodi Schwan, Founder, Align Content Studio | Publisher, Sioux Falls Business and Pigeon 605.
Tuesday, October 1, 3-6 PM, Sioux Falls Convention Center. Register for in person or online viewing at https:/bit.ly/4bWHmC5 or visit sdchamber.biz and review the Special Events listing.
We are committed to fostering an engaging and interactive environment. We believe that true understanding and insight emerge through dynamic dialogue. Audience members are encouraged to participate by asking questions and exchange ideas with our esteemed speakers. By facilitating this open exchange of thoughts and inquiries, we aim to enrich the learning experience for everyone involved, making our seminar a truly collaborative and enlightening event.
Thank you for your support of the South Dakota Chamber of Commerce & Industry!
|